After-Before Friday Forum Week 26

After 4 weeks of suspense, the participants of the ABFriday Anniversary Challenge  are simultaneously unveiling their individual interpretations of a single image selected by our readers.  The original image selected by the readers–an excellent choice I might add–is shown below.  You can see the other ten at Stacy’s ABFriday Forum Week 26.


Reader’s Choice: Original Image

Knowing that nearly a dozen other talented post-processors will be working on exactly the same image as you are has an interesting effect on one’s approach to the post-processing.  In my case, the two choices were: 1) Should I use the approach I normally use with my own images and bring out what the eye (probably) saw when taking the picture? or 2) Try something different?  It was a pretty easy choice: It would be Door Number 2!

Actually, as it turns out, I went through both doors because the only way to Door Number 2 was to first pass through Door Number 1.

The changes seen here were all made using various options in Photoshop’s Filter tool kit.  First, I made a number of adjustments in the Basic tab of the Camera Raw Filter as shown in the screen capture below (red arrows).

Robin Kent ABFriday Week 26 Before 02Adjustments in Camera Raw Filter, Basic Tab

These changes brought out the strong colors and enhanced the contrast of the scene. But more was needed to add some drama to the sky and the water in the foreground.  Switching to the Gradient tab of the Camera Raw Filter, I moved the exposure slider to -1.7  (red arrow) and applied two gradients, one for the sky and one for the water (yellow arrows).

Robin Kent ABFriday Week 26 Before 03

Note that the angle of the gradient for the water is parallel to the river’s edge.  I clicked the OK button and the results of the steps so far are shown below. It is a nice image and I suspect pretty close to what Karen was seeing when she took the picture (but she will be the judge of that).

 Robin Kent ABFriday Riverfront Before 04Results of Camera Raw Filter Adjustments

 At this point the image was ready to go through Door 2.  I will admit up front that the process from here was one of enthusiastic experimentation because I intentionally chose an area of Photoshop that I had never visited before and a lot of rejects are lying on the virtual cutting room floor.  To save you from a detailed description of the many dead ends I encountered let’s go straight to the series of steps that produced the final result.

So after a fair amount of time, I clicked Filter >Stylize>Extrude.  The dialog box that appeared is shown in the screen capture below.

Robin Kent ABFriday Riverfront Before 05The “Extrude” Process

 The settings shown (red arrows) are those that I chose, not the default settings.  This is a really cool tool, and different choices on these settings can produce radically different results.  The final result is shown below.

Robin Kent ABFriday Riverfront After

Final Result

I liked what I saw here because it reminded me just a little of Cubism which set in motion the modern art movement of the early 20th century.  I’ll be interested in what you think.

Don’t forget to see the other interpretations by the other participants.  You can get to them by clicking here.  I can’t wait to see them myself.

26 thoughts on “After-Before Friday Forum Week 26

  1. Pingback: The Afters! After-Before Friday Anniversary Challenge | Visual Venturing

    • Thanks, Cee. I appreciate that. Yes, This has been totally fun. I haven’t made it to all the individual posts yet, but I have been so impressed by the diversity of creative ideas. I was particularly taken by yours with the two completely different results between a vertical and horizontal crop(plus the additional touches, of course).


  2. My first inclination was to go to an extreme but I stifled it as much as possible. I’m glad you didn’t. I think it’s necessary to process the way you normally do before adding or exaggerating an effect. This works great because below it is a well processed image. I love what you did though I doubt I would ever use the effect. But as soon as I saw it I said to myself, “Yeah, I wish I had had the guts to go all the way! Great job.


    • Thanks, Emilio. Thanks for checking it out. I started sooner than normal–almost as soon as the image was announced, so I knew I had plenty of time to back off if nothing good was happening. Always good to have an emergency exit available, especially if no Plan B has been prepared;-)


  3. I was tempted to apply a pastel or water colour effect to mine but held back. I like what you have done, it has a geometric feel as well as something like finger painting. Great work, I have never used the extrude filter will need to play with it now.


    • Thanks, Ben. I appreciate the comments. Your process gave me several new ideas as well. The extrude filter looks like an interesting little tool. First time for me too. I’ll plan to try it some more.


  4. Robin this is inspired! It totally satisfies the artist’s thirst…and definitely a touch of cubism.
    I just love everything about it… thanks so much for the tutes.. I definitely want to play with this tool.
    I didn’t know it existed 🙂
    A wonderful result!

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Hi, Robin. Well, what a bad post hostess I’ve been on this, taking until today to comment on everyone’s submissions. But it’s fun to see them all again with a set of fresh eyes! First, I love what you said about having to go through door number one before experimenting through door number 2. I find there are no shortcuts when it comes to post-processing. Play as you will, if the image isn’t as strong enough as you feel you can make it with basic adjustments, the after effect will never be as strong.

    The extrude filter seems similar to “detail extractor” in Nik Color Efex Pro (which is what I used for my monochrome image). It’s definitely fun to experiment, and like you, I had quite a few copies end up in my trash bin. So glad you went out on a limb – it was so un-Robinlike in its treatment, and that’s what makes it so much fun!

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Pingback: One Four Challenge – Nov wk 4 – Polls.. and December’s challenge | Captivate Me

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s